Best Eats for Super Bowl in Westchester

by Katie Schlientz

These Westchester restaurants score a touch down with their Super Bowl offerings! Do some super snacking with these Super Bowl packages to go:

AJ’s Burgers
For a more traditional option, you can’t go wrong with AJ’s Super Bowl Feast for $99, which includes 36 Wings, 6 Sliders, 20 Meatballs, 20 Dogs in Dough (aka Pigs in a Blanket!), and Garlic Rolls with Marinara Dipping Sauce.
To order: 914-235-3009
AJ’s Burger’s: 542 North Ave, New Rochelle, NY 10801; 914-235-3009;

Broccoli’s Luncheonette
Starting Monday, February 1st, two sandwiches will face off at Broccoli’s Luncheonette—the Tampa Bay Lechon with roast pork, onions, and mojo sauce and the Kanas City BBQ Burger. The latter features our 4-oz house made burger with Kansas City BBQ sauce, Jack Daniel onions, bacon, and Swiss cheese. Both will be on special the entire week for $9 each.
To order:
Broccoli’s Luncheonette: 23 Cedar Street, Dobbs Ferry, NY, 10522; 914-693-8000;

Chef Scott Fratangelo is having a bit of BBQ fun with this year’s Super Bowl package, which can be picked up hot from the Ardsley eatery on game day. Simply select between his Sweet Chili Lime Chicken Wings with Scallion Aioli Dip or his House Made BBQ Pulled Pork with Potato Rolls and Pickles. Both will be served with Rigatoni Mac and Cheese and Wedge Salad. The package serves four people for $125.
To order: (Order by February 4th)
L’inizio: 698 Saw Mill River Road, Ardsley, NY 10502; 914-693-5400;

Jay Street Cafe
Husband and wife team Matt and Christina Safarowic continue to kill it in Katonah with their menus, so it’s no surprise their Super Bowl specials score high. Their half trays—feeding 4 to 5 people—include items like Wings ($65), Nachos ($60), Poutine ($50), Buffalo Cauliflower ($50), and more.
To order:
Jay Street Cafe: 63 Katonah Ave, Katonah NY 10536; 914-488-9700;

The White Plains fast Italian hot spot teamed up with I Heart Wines and Basei Beer to create two game day packages which feed four people. The wine lovers package ($59) includes two dozen XL Wings, two Margherita Pinsas, an order of Mozzarella Sticks and 4-pack of wine with I Heart Wines ice bucket, napkins, and koozie. The beer package ($65) includes the same food offerings plus a 6-pack of Basei Beer and koozies. For the wings, fans can select between Cacio e Pepe or “Italian” Buffalo Sauce (Hot). PLUS! You can add a tray of one of our lasagnas— Homemade, Gluten-Free Veggie, or Porcini-Truffle Mushroom!
To order: 914-328-6535 (Order by February 4th)
Papi’: 19 Bank Street, White Plains, 10606; 914-328-6535;

The Greekish
Get ready for the Super Bowl with The Greekish Super-ish Super Bowl Party Pack for four for $45. This Meze pack includes: two dips of choice plus chips and pita, Feta Croquettes, Meatballs, Wings, Brussels Sprouts, and Roasted Cauliflower. The package is available at both the Nyack and Harrison locations.
To order: (Order by February 5th)
The Greekish: 8 North Broadway, Nyack, NY 10960; 845-353-1200; or 273 Halstead Avenue, Harrison NY 10528; 914-732-3333;

The Rare Bit
When it comes to Super Bowl munchies, The Rare Bit has you covered. With a family-style menu that includes their delicious Chicken Wings ($35) in a range of sauces (Buffalo, BBQ, General Tso’s, Kung Pao, or Nashville), Mac and Cheese ($30), Sandwich Platter ($35), Sliders ($35), Taters ($30) and more, there’s something for the entire family, no matter who you are rooting for! All orders can be picked up Sunday, February 7, from 12:00 to 6:00 PM.
To order: 415-816-5833 or email [email protected]
The Rare Bit: 23 Cedar Street, Dobbs Ferry, NY, 10522; 914-693-8000;

The Shop Ardsley
The Ardsley hybrid restaurant—serving bagels and breakfast in the AM before transforming into a full-scale American restaurant after 4:00 PM—will be airing the big game on all three 55-inch TV screens with full sound. If you decide to stay to watch the game, check out their Chicken Wing offerings (8 for $11; 16 for $20) available with Teriyaki, BBQ, Mild or Hot sauces. If you’re enjoying the game at home, check out their Build Your Own Burger option or pick up one of their coveted Fried Chicken dinners ($12-$58) to go!
To order: 914-591-4321 
The Shop Ardsley: 711 Saw Mill River Road, Ardsley, NY, 10502; 914-591-4321;

You may also like